A platform for testing the performance of metaheuristics solving the energy resource management problem in smart grids

Due to the importance of the energy resource management (ERM) in the energy community, several mathematical formulations have been successfully proposed to solve the problem. However, due to the very dynamic evolution of power systems and the transformation of electrical grids, mainly due to the development of smart grid technologies, traditional formulations, which were designed for an entirely different scenario, sometimes cannot deal with the problem efficiently. It is in those situations, where traditional approaches fail, that modern metaheuristic optimizers have demonstrated been a potent tool to face such challenges. In this paper, we present “Meta-ERM”, a MATLAB© platform designed to assess the performance of modern metaheuristics when solving the ERM problem.

The energy resource management (ERM) has been considered one of the most complicated optimization problems in power systems due to its combinatorial nature, nonlinearities and a large number of energy resources which leads to high dimensionality and highly constrained problems (Soares et al. 2016; Soares et al. 2018). Therefore, adequate optimization frameworks and extensive analysis of case studies are a crucial part of the new paradigm brought the by the smart grid operation.

One of the main challenges in the new power system paradigm is that advanced (and occasionally expensive) infrastructure is required to study, validate, and provide accurate projections about how efficient a new control algorithm can be in real implementations. Besides, when a new approach to solve the ERM problem is proposed, it is desired to include a broad range of aspects that can impact its performance (i.e., scalability, uncertainty, memory requirements, operational costs) before real implementation (Di Somma et al. 2018). In this situation, ERM simulation platforms can provide a more accurate perception of the impact of different aspects of a new solution before the actual execution takes place (Yan et al. 2013; Cheng et al. 2017; Lezama et al. 2018a).

In this paper, we present “Meta-ERM”, a MATLAB© platform for solving energy resource management problems using stochastic optimization techniques. The platform allows the optimization of large-scale centralized day-ahead scheduling problems with the use of modern metaheuristic algorithms (e.g., PSO, DE, GA, SA, ABC, and others) (Talbi 2009; Faia et al. 2017). The simulation tool has been designed to easy test and assess the performance of any existing metaheuristic.

Meta-ERM platform solves the energy resource management problem faced by an aggregator (see Fig. 1) aiming at procuring energy needs from distributed resources and the electricity market. The aggregator looks for the minimization of operational costs while making revenues from selling energy in available electricity markets. Moreover, it may use its assets, e.g., energy storage systems (ESS), to supply the load demand. The main idea is that the optimization software performs the energy resource scheduling of the dedicated resources for the 24 h of the following day (i.e., day-ahead scheduling).

Overview of the aggregator energy management problem

Full size image

Even with state-of-the-art solvers, it is somehow difficult to provide efficient solutions to some of the scenarios that can be faced in the context of large-scale ERM problems. Therefore, the final purpose of the Meta-ERM platform is to be used for the assessment and comparison of stochastic optimization algorithms (e.g., PSO or DE) to mitigate the exponential execution time and large memory requirements using traditional mathematical tools. Moreover, due to the stochastic nature of these optimizers, an assessment tool is of particular interest for the scientific community working in the development of such approaches.

The “Meta-ERM” platform was designed using building-blocks that represent functions (i.e., scripts) with specific targets. The simulation platform has been implemented in MATLAB© 2016 64-bit. As shown in Fig. 2, some scripts can be encrypted (blue color in the figure), in case the information concerning a specific function cannot be disclosed. Also, with this capability, users interested in testing new algorithms can be focused on modifying (or implementing from scratch) only two scripts, namely:

1. i)

   one script for setting the parameters required by their algorithm (A.2).

2. ii)

   a second script for the implementation of their proposed solution method (A.6). Some applications of the platform can be found in (Soares et al. 2016; Lezama et al. 2018b).

General overview of the platform

Full size image

The simulation platform is already configured to allow users choose from a wide variate of case studies (e.g., buildings or microgrids with resources from renewables to EVs) and a comprehensive set of evolutionary algorithms including PSO, DE (in different variants), QPSO, ABC, GA, and others.

Since the performance of stochastic optimizers typically requires a statistical assessment of the provided results, “Meta-ERM” has the capability of configuring many runs and provide statistical indicators (e.g., mean fitness value, execution time, convergence rate) to determine the statistical relevance of the results. This data is provided in the form of output Tables (not shown in the paper for space limitation).

Additionally, the platform is also able to provide a set of different plots for analysis of the solutions. The user can easily configure the type of plots they want to recover from a simulation. The plots are not only limited to the analysis of the quality of the solution provided by an algorithm regarding the scheduling of resources (see, for instance, Fig. 3, but also to the insights concerning the performance of an algorithm (or a group of algorithms) in terms of fitness quality, convergence, robustness or other indicators (see, for instance, Figs. 4 and 5).

Plots of power scheduling generated with Meta-ERM platform

Full size image

Heatmaps of metaheuristic parameter tuning generated with Meta-ERM platform

Full size image

Plot of algorithms’ convergence generated with Meta-ERM platform

Full size image

A graphical user interface (GUI) is currently under development for the “Meta-ERM” platform (see Fig. 6). Earlier versions of this platform, without GUI, have demonstrated their value for the scientific community through algorithm competition initiatives launched at major and prominent international events (cf. IEEE PES GM 2017 (Lezama et al. 2018b) and WCCI 2018 (Lezama et al. 2017)). The GUI is intended to ease the process of testing algorithms. Through simple menus, the user can choose from over a wide range of case studies/algorithms and tune some global parameters. The GUI interface can be updated periodically, adding functionalities, case studies and algorithms on the go.

GUI tool

Full size image

“Meta-ERM” platform is a tool designed to test and validate the performance of metaheuristics when solving the ERM problem in smart grids. Different functionalities are provided by the platform, for instance, different case studies can be selected, a set of popular metaheuristics is available for comparison and performance validation, capabilities for statistical analysis and plot functionalities, among other options. Moreover, because of the building-block structure, new approaches can be implemented and integrated into the platform easily, allowing to expand the state of the art regarding metaheuristic optimization on power systems.

ABC:

Artificial Bee Colony

DE:

Differential Evolution

ERM:

Energy Resource Management

ESS:

Energy Storage System

EVs:

Electric Vehicles

GA:

Genetic Algorithm

GM:

General Meeting

GUI:

Graphical User Interface

IEEE:

Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers

PES:

Power Energy Society

PSO:

Particle Swarm Optimization

QPSO:

Quantum Particle Swarm Optimization

SA:

Simulate Annealing

WCCI:

World Congress on Computational Intelligence

We thank the support of the IEEE PES Working Group on Modern Heuristic Optimization (WGMHO) and the IEEE CIS Task Force on Computational Intelligence in the Energy Domain in the realization of competition initiatives. We would also like to show our gratitude to the Research Group on Intelligent Engineering and Computing for Advanced Innovation and Development (GECAD).

This work has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 641794 project DREAM-GO.

Funding

This work has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement No. 641794 project DREAM-GO.

Availability of data and materials

The platform has been used in optimization competition initiatives launched at major and prominent international events. The guidelines and codes are available on-line in:

IEEE PES GM2007 (testbed 2).

http://sites.ieee.org/psace-mho/2017-smart-grid-operation-problems-competition-panel/

WCCI 2018 (Evolutionary Computation in Uncertain Environments: A Smart Grid Application).

http://www.gecad.isep.ipp.pt/WCCI2018-SG-COMPETITION/

About this supplement

This article has been published as part of Energy Informatics Volume 1 Supplement 1, 2018: Proceedings of the 7th DACH+ Conference on Energy Informatics. The full contents of the supplement are available online at https://energyinformatics.springeropen.com/articles/supplements/volume-1-supplement-1.

Affiliations

1. GECAD Research Group, School of Engineering, Polytechnic of Porto, Porto, Portugal
   • Fernando Lezama
   •  & Joao Soares
2. Polytechnic of Porto, Porto, Portugal
   • Zita Vale

Contributions

All the authors have read and approved the final manuscript. All authors contributed equally to this work.

Corresponding author

Correspondence to Fernando Lezama.

Competing interests

The authors declare that they have no competing interests.

Publisher’s Note

Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.

Reprints and Permissions