Table 7 Table comparing related works on testbeds environments
From: An integrated testbed for locally monitoring SCADA systems in smart grids
Work | Availability | Integration | Network | Power | Extensibility | Protocols |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Davis et al. (2006) (2008) | LIC | Server requests over VPN | RINSE, TCP/IP | Power- World | HIL | Modbus, TCP/IP |
Lin et al. (2011) | OS* | C++/Java | ns2 | PSFL | Not discussed | Not discussed |
Levesque et al. (2012) | OS* | HTTP requests | Omnet++ | OpenDSS | Not discussed | Not discussed |
Sadi et al. (2015) | LIC | C | OPNET | Matlab/ Simulink | Not discussed | Not discussed |
Kang et al. (2015) | TB | Physical links | IEC61850 device | PV simulator | Not discussed | Modbus, IEC61850 |
Koutsandria et al. (2015) | HIL/ TB | C, C++, Python | Modbus | Matlab/ Simulink | Other protocols | Modbus, TCP/IP |
Awad et al. (2016) | OS | C++ | Omnet++ | OpenDSS | Not discussed | TCP/IP, 802.11, Ethernet |
Gunthilaka et al. (2016) | LIC | Java | IEC61850 simulator | Power- World | Other protocols | IEC-104, IEC61850 |
The proposed approach (2017) | OS | Python | Modbus simulator | PyPower | Other protocols; other SG elements | Modbus, TCP/IP |