Skip to main content

Advertisement

Table 6 Comparison of process-aware IDS techniques

From: An integrated testbed for locally monitoring SCADA systems in smart grids

Work Approach Sector Validation Detection Prevention Rules Location
Hadžiosmanović et al. (2014) Learned ICS (tank) TB, RS Yes No Static Local
Lin et al. (2013; 2016) Specification PG SIM Yes Yes Dynamic Central
Urbina et al. (2016) Specification ICS, PG SIM, TB, RS Yes No Dynamic Local
Koutsandria et al. (2015; 2014), Parvania et al. (2014)) Specification PG TB Yes Yes Dynamic (not yet) Local
Caselli et al. (2015) Learned ICS RS Yes No Static Local
Nivethan and Papa (2016b); Nivethan and Papa (2016a) Specification PG None Yes No Static Local
Bao et al. (2016) Specification PG SIM Yes No Dynamic Distributed
Mashima et al. (2016) Specification PG SIM Yes Yes Dynamic Distributed Delay, Central Detection
The proposed approach Specification PG SIM Yes Yes Dynamic Local
  1. ICS - Industrial Control Systems, PG - Power Grid, SIM - Simulation, TB - TestBed, RS - Real System (or trace)