Skip to main content

Table 8 Interoperability layers allocated in features and selected articles

From: Methodology for identifying technical details of smart energy solutions and research gaps in smart grid: an example of electric vehicles in the energy system

Feature number

10 selected articles

Frequence of layers in features

(Hilshey et al. 2012)

(Li et al. 2012)

(McGee et al. n.d.)

(Nicanfar et al. 2013)

(Ahmad and Sivasubramani 2015)

(Santos et al. 2015)

(Yang and Tseng 2015)

(Budde Christensen et al. 2012)

(Rezania and Prüggler 2012)

(Zhong and You 2012)

1

C

C,F

C,F

C,F

C,F

C,F,B

C

C,B

C,F

C,B

10,7,3,0,0

2

C,F,I

  

C, F,Cc

 

C,F

  

C

 

4,3,0,1,1

3

C,F,I

       

F

 

1,2,0,1,0

4

C,F

      

C,F

C

 

3,2,0,0,0

5

 

F,B

      

F,I

 

0,2,1,1,0

6

 

C,F

C,F

 

B

     

2,2,1,0,0

7

 

C

C

   

C

C,B

C,B

 

5,0,2,0,0

8

  

C,F

       

1,1,0,0,0

9

  

B

  

B,F

 

B

B

 

0,1,4,0,0

10

  

I,Cc

I,Cc

      

0,0,0,2,2

11

   

C

      

1,0,0,0,0

12

   

C,F

 

C

    

2,1,0,0,0

13

     

F

    

0,1,0,0,0

14

     

C,F,B

    

1,1,1,0,0

15

     

F,B, I,Cc

  

I

 

0,1,1,2,1

16

     

C

    

1,0,0,0,0

17

       

B

  

0,0,1,0,0

Frequence of layers in articles

4,4,0,1,0

3,3,1,0,0

4,3,1,1,1

4,3,0,1,2

1,1,1,0,0

5,6,4,1,1

2,0,0,0,0

3,1,4,0,0

4,3,2,2,0

1,0,1,0,0

31,24,14,7,4

  1. Note: Component (C), function (F), business (B), information (I), communication (Cc)